Skip to main content

Stopping the search for work-life balance

This school year has been different than any other before because my daughter was born six days before I returned to work to run 9th grade orientation and professional development for my staff. In the months prior to the birth our our second child my wife and I agreed that I would start the school year to get the ball rolling and delay my paternity leave until three weeks into the year. I ran at a breakneck pace to serve both the school and my growing family and after three weeks I said goodbye to school and got onto an airplane to travel with my wife, toddler and newborn; which was a decision that was challenging but I knew was right for my family and for me as an individual.

 A week into my paternity leave I woke up to a flurry of messages from students and colleagues that informed me that there was a tragic accident at the school and that a student had passed away the previous night. I sat on the couch frozen in disbelief in both the death and the reality that I was a thousand miles away from the students and community travelling with my family and just starting my leave. That moment was the most helpless I had ever felt as an educator because a student who I had taught and who had written me a goodbye note before I left was no longer with us and I knew that my travels would keep me away from the vigil, the funeral and from the community that I love.

Just minutes after hearing the news my toddler woke up and, in his innocent voice unable to read my emotions asked for his oatmeal and wondered out loud if we were going to the beach that day. My wife walked out with our newborn and the day began like the others had as we prepped for our day’s adventure and spent time laughing and playing while internally I was nothing short of destroyed. It was in that mourning and breathing in that helplessness that I verified a thought that had been ruminating in my mind for years: in this line of work that ideal state of “work-life balance” will never be achieved and the pursuit of that goal was more dangerous than I had ever imagined.


The Reality of Our Divided Selves

Though I am writing predominately about education and to educators I firmly believe that this topic impacts anyone who works with people because that work is never finished and the development of people is always in progress. Unlike projects with due dates and deliverables we work to build capacity in a customer that can never be a finished product. I am at a school and in a community that can take 100% of me at any given time. I do not hold bitterness for the needs of my students and school and if I had no boundaries, no family needing my attention or no accountability in my life I would work around the clock always looking to develop this person or that one just a bit more. In short, if I could give everything I would without hesitation. However, as soon as I feel like I could not be more invested in anything more than my work I walk in the door and captivated by the beauty of my children and the value of my marriage knowing that I would give up the work in a second if it meant that I could be with them full-time.  This is the core of why balance for me and I believe for all educators will never be reached because we desire to give ourselves to people not products and people can never be finished.

 This division between work and family is enough in itself does not mention my commitment to my church, the cultivation of friendship, my desire to ski on Wednesday when it snows and not on Saturdays with the crowds or even just to do the unspeakable: to stop and rest. If I could, I would give 100% of myself to my job, 100% of myself to my family and 100% of myself to the aspects of my life that are for simple enjoyment. There is no balance to be found here,  no calendar structure or app that can make this work just the need for those around me to know that I am a divided person, as we all are, with the desire to give my all to all at the same time.  

It is for this reason that work/life balance cannot be an individual pursuit but a community endeavor. The best we can do as a community of colleagues is to help one another realize that by nature we are all divided and that nothing we do or say should hinder our pursuit of wholeness in our field of work.  
Balancing together

Two days after receiving the news about the death of our student I received another steady flurry of text messages; each of them carrying with them the same theme: Chris, I know you are hurting with this loss but know that your family at school is there for our kids and your family at home is what you need to focus on right now.

In my guilt for being gone and with my desire to be with kids I was reassured by my colleagues that my commitment to my family after the birth of my second child was essential even in the midst of our collective mourning and struggle. The answer to riddle work/life balance came to me in that instant. I realized that balance was not found in the number of hours spent at home versus at school or how many of my vacation days I take but rather that I have (and we should all have) a community of colleagues that was happy to fill in during my absence and that reassured me I was no less of an educator because at the time when my community needed me the most I was simply busy being a father.


So our answer is not to put work/life balance in the hands of the individual but should be a collective responsibility. The creation of a community that supports the development of colleagues just like it supports the development of students will help alleviate the tension found as we individually search for balance. When I encourage my co-worker who is walking out of the door early to get to yoga I am taking care of them and if I question their professionalism or work-ethic because they are leaving I am not contributing to their growth but undermining our common desire for wholeness. I would never question a student who was walking out of the building to get to their extracurricular activity, rather I would encourage their participation so why would I ever question when my colleagues are working to better their whole selves and not just their work selves? Work-life balance is not a fight to engage in as an individual but rather a goal that a staff should embark upon together as we ask one another about our kids, our families, our vacations and our rest. Because of our commitment to the development of kids many of us will never be able to stop on our own but together we can work to keep one another rested, content and balanced. I will never again hope to find work/life balance on my own but will commit to know my colleagues as individuals who are fighting to fulfill and enjoy each aspect of their divided selves and who know that I am working to do the same. 

Comments

  1. I appreciate this post. You know it hits at my core belief that we must avoid the divided self and ensure a healthy whole. It can only be done in and with a community that seeks every individual to be a healthy whole that contributes to a healthy whole. There is no balance, there is being. We must contribute to healthy being of every individual within our community. Blessings to you!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Wow. As a mom I really appreciate this post. This is a lovely essay. I wish I could broadcast it in 100 foot high characters across the sky. Congratulations to you and your wife. Love and laud to your colleagues.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Teaching through the Tension of Privilege

I live across the street from my school and many of my students live in the blocks surrounding my home. I see them after school, on the weekends and throughout the summer and the decision to be both an educator in and member of this community has been a choice that I have never regretted but one that I think about often. It is clear to me that though I am acquiring the language of east Denver and though I can navigate conversations around violence, poverty and inequity within my school and my community I will never truly know what it means to live as many of my students do nor will I ever pretend that I completely understand how life works in this community for them.  It has become apparent to me that my students and myself share the same street name but we live in very different neighborhoods. My neighborhood is one of proximity to amenities, rising home values and a future full of choice for my own children while the neighborhood my students live in is often underserved,  o...

Four Lessons Learned in the Work of Shifting School Culture

The work of shifting school culture can be overwhelming and often lonely because culture leaders are caught in a tension between where the school's culture currently lies and where it needs to be in order to serve students better. As a dedicated school culture leader in my building I have become comfortable with both feeling like I own the current school culture in both its good and its bad as well as the keeper of the vision for where it needs to be in order for the school to be a more dynamic place for all stakeholders. Below are four lessons I have learned as a first year Dean of Culture and shed light on the long and extensive process of shifting culture. 1. It is essential to have a shared mental model of "school culture". One of the first realizations I had as a Dean of Culture for two schools is that "culture" is such a significant bucket that encompasses the experience of of students, staff and stakeholders in a variety of ways. Culture is the summ...

No Superheros Needed: Effective Coaching is Built in Layers not by Individuals

Too often the image of an instructional coach is that of an overworked and stressed educator with frizzy hair and coffee stains dotting their wrinkled outfit. Their schedules are maxed out and often double booked and, often removed from their personal working space, they navigate busy hallways filled with kids while balancing their computer, notebook, resources and an empty water bottle that they committed to filling during the day but have had no time for even the briefest moment of self-care.    Full time coaches often have a large caseload of teachers spanning across grades, content areas and sometimes even different school sites and teacher leaders are tasked with managing both the significant responsibility of creating and model classroom and building the capacity of their peers while juggling a number of semi-administrative tasks. School administrators often and incorrectly look for instructional superheroes who can become coaches as a way to scale the success that t...